Where Every Slice Feels Like Home.
Our story
At Carol Ann's Pizza, we take pride in serving up homemade pizzas, famous Friday fish fry, hearty lasagna, flavorful wings, and our signature homemade garlic breads. Family-owned and dedicated to quality, we bring comfort and flavor to every meal, making every visit feel like home.
Hot Deals & Happenings
🐣 Easter Family Meal Pans
Order by April 7th for pick-up on April 19th.
Choose from:
Lasagna
Chicken Pesto Pasta
Chicken Alfredo
Spaghetti & Meatballs
All meals include:
2 orders of homemade garlic bread
Small pans feed ~4 people
Large pans feed up to 10 people
Par-bake pizzas and large salads also available!
Call now to reserve your pans!
(262) 628-8237
Dining Room Remodel
Our new dining rooms are complete — and looking great! Stop in and see what’s changed.
🍟 Daily Offerings
We offer a wide variety of daily options including:
Appetizers
Sandwiches with homemade buns
Salads
Fish fries on Friday
Shrimp dinners
Italian beef sandwich (a customer favorite!)
All French fries are hand-cut.
Menu
PIZZA
Pizzas are made to order with homemade dough.
Available in thin, regular, and thick crust:
- Small 12″, Medium 14″, or Large 16″
- Gluten-free 10″ crust available
Extra charges apply for thick crust, sides of Parmesan, red pepper flakes, pizza sauce, hot sauce, teriyaki sauce, BBQ sauce, ranch.
Specialty Pizzas
- Canadian Bacon & Pineapple
- Chicken Bacon Ranch
- BBQ Chicken
- BLT
- Gyro
- Par-bake pizzas
Finish cooking at home when you’re ready!
Toppings Available:
Cheese
- 100% Grande Mozzarella
Meats
- Sausage, Pepperoni, Canadian Bacon, Hamburger, Chicken, Bacon
Veggies
- Onion, Black Olives, Jalapeño, Pepperoncini, Green Olive, Pineapple, Mushrooms, Green Pepper, Tomato
Seafood
- Anchovies
APPETIZERS
- Garlic Bread (homemade)
- Garlic Bread with Cheese (homemade)
- Jalapeño Cream Cheese Poppers
- Mushrooms
- Broccoli Cheddar Bites
- Cheddar Cheese Balls
- Mozzarella Sticks
- Chicken Strip Appetizer
- French Fries (hand-cut)
- Onion Rings (shredded)
- Mac N Cheese Bites
- Chicken Wings
- (Hot, BBQ, Teriyaki, or Plain) – 6 or 12 per order
SALADS
- Grilled or Crispy Chicken Salad – Includes onion, tomato, black olives, and mozzarella cheese
- Garden Salad – Includes onion, tomato, black olives, and mozzarella cheese
- Veggie Salad – Includes onion, tomato, black olives, mushrooms, and green peppers
Served with a slice of garlic bread and your choice of dressing: ranch, French, thousand island, or creamy Italian.
SANDWICHES
All sandwiches are grilled to perfection and come with hand-cut French Fries.
Substitute onion rings for an additional charge.
- 1/3# Hamburger
- 1/3# Cheeseburger
- 2/3# Hamburger
- 2/3# Cheeseburger
- Grilled Cheese (American and Mozzarella) with Bacon and Tomato
- Steak Sandwich with fried onions, mushrooms, and mozzarella cheese
- Dano – 1/3# hamburger patty and a 1/3# Italian sausage patty with mozzarella cheese and BBQ sauce
- Italian Sausage Sandwich with sauce and mozzarella cheese
- Breaded Chicken Sandwich with lettuce, tomato, and mayo
- BLT
Additional toppings: Onions, Lettuce, Tomato, Mushrooms, Black Olives, Green Pepper
Cheeses: American, Mozzarella
Bacon and extra cheese available for an additional charge.
KIDS MENU
- 6″ Cheese Pizza
on regular crust
Additional pizza toppings available for an extra charge. - Chicken Strips Basket with homemade French Fries – Choice of Ranch, BBQ, or Honey Mustard dipping sauce
- Grilled Cheese
(American, Cheddar, and Mozzarella) with French Fries
FISH FRY - FRIDAYS
Dinners include hand-cut French fries, rye bread, coleslaw, and a lemon wedge.
Onion rings or potato pancakes with applesauce can be substituted for an additional charge.
- Fried Cod (beer-battered)
- Baked Cod
Hours
- Sun - Thu
- -
- Fri - Sat
- -
